The Pros and Cons of Leather vs. Fabric Recliners

One of the biggest decisions when shopping for a new recliner is whether to choose leather or fabric upholstery. Both options have unique benefits and drawbacks.

Leather stands up well over decades and has an elegant, upscale look. But it comes with a higher price tag and requires more meticulous care. Fabrics like microfiber and polyester cost less, clean easily, and come in endless color and pattern options to match any decor.

In this in-depth guide, we’ll compare leather versus fabric recliners across all factors so you can determine the best upholstery for your needs.

Leather Recliners – Pros and Cons

Full grain leather recliners carry an aura of luxury and sophistication. But they have some downsides to consider as well.

Pros

• Timeless, elegant appearance
• Withstands many years of use
• Develops a handsome patina over time
• Feels cool and soft against skin
• Conforms to body shape
• Available in many colors

Cons

• Expensive – costs thousands for high-end models
• Requires meticulous care and maintenance
• Absorbs body oils and shows dirt readily
• Scratches, scuffs, and punctures show clearly and are hard to repair
• Can crack, peel and dry out over time without proper conditioning
• Sun exposure fades colors faster
• Lacks ability to have patterns

Fabric Recliners – Pros and Cons

For a more budget-friendly option, today’s fabric recliners offer great durability, easy cleanability, and wide style selection.

Pros

• Hundreds of fabric patterns and colors to choose from
• Stain-resistant properties of many synthetic fabrics
• Simple spot cleaning keeps them looking new
• Affordably priced between $200-$1000
• Microfiber mimics leather feel for less
• Cushions retain shape well over time
• Pet hair blends in and cleans up easily

Cons

• Fabrics like chenille and velvet crush easily
• Not as soft and supple as quality leather
• More casual, less upscale aesthetic
• Cushions must be fluffed to maintain loft
• Pets can damage with scratches and clawing
• Sunlight fades fabric over time in some cases

Key Differences Between Leather and Fabric Recliners

How To Choose Leather vs. Fabric

Choosing leather versus fabric largely depends on your budget, decor, lifestyle and maintenance preferences.

Leather works best if you:

• Prefer an elegant, upscale look that ages beautifully
• Don’t have kids or pets that could damage it
• Aren’t bothered by cracks and creases that develop
• Are prepared to properly clean and condition it routinely

Fabric is better if you:

• Have pets whose hair and scratches would ruin leather
• Want a range of colors/patterns to match your decor
• Prefer machine washable convenience for simple cleaning
• Need family-friendly and kid-proof durability
• Are on a tight budget

Whichever you select, inspect build quality closely rather than assuming leather or fabric alone means a well-made chair. A cheap fabric can still outlast poor quality leather. Test recliners in person and read reviews to ensure excellent comfort, materials, and construction.

Invest in Quality Craftsmanship

The recliner upholstery decision ultimately comes down to your budget, lifestyle fit, and design preferences. Leather’s refined elegance versus endless fabric variety ensures there’s an option for every taste. Just be sure to buy from reputable brands using top-grade materials so your recliner provides lasting comfort and style for years on end.